Displaying 201 - 300 of 364
| # | Agency | Office Name | Scheme |
Is discovery permitted by either party at the hearing-level stage? |
Briefly describe the scope and type(s) of discovery available (e.g., depositions, interrogatories, etc.) | Verified by Agency |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 201 | Department of Health and Human Services | Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals | HHSOOBEN0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | Discovery is permitted if CMS or a CMS contractor elects party status in the appeal -- see 42 CFR 405.1037. Under Part 405 adjudications, CMS and CMS contractors may not elect party status if the appellant is an unrepresented beneficiary. Under Part 422 adjudications, the application of the 405 discovery rule is unclear -- the managed care plan (a type of CMS contractor) has party status pursuant to the statute. In Part 423 adjudications, CMS and CMS contractors are not permitted to take party status -- their role is limited to "participant" status, thus no discovery is permitted. Discovery can include limited depositions, interrogatories and document requests are allowed. | Verified |
| 202 | Department of Labor | Board of Alien Labor Certification Appeals (BALCA) | LABRBALC0006 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | Discovery is only permitted in cases where a hearing is set under 20 CFR §§ 655.171(b) or 656.27(e). Depositions upon oral examination or written questions; written interrogatories; production of documents or other evidence for inspection and other purposes; and requests for admission. (29 CFR § 18.13) | Verified |
| 203 | General Services Administration | Civilian Board of Contract Appeals | GSAOCBCA0004 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | Interrogatories, requests for admission, requests for production, depositions, and subpoenas compelling witnesses to produce books/papers/documents at a hearing or deposition. See 48 CFR 6101.13 - .16. | Verified |
| 204 | Department of Health and Human Services | Office of Hearings and Inquiries | HHSOOHAI0003 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | Discovery is permitted for the Medicaid State Plan Amendment cases pursuant to 42 CFR 430.86 | Verified |
| 205 | Small Business Administration | Office of Hearing and Appeal | SBAOGNRL0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | Requests for admissions, requests for production of documents, interrogatories, and depositions. See 13 CFR 134.213(b). The scope of discovery does not differ based upon the type of case, but a party may obtain discovery only upon motion, and for good cause shown. See 13 CFR 134.213(a). Also see 13CFR 134.301 (Size Determinations and NAICS code designations and 13 CFR 134.511 (Service Disabled Veteran Small Business Concerns). | Verified |
| 206 | Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System | Board of Governors | FRSXBOAR0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | Depositions are allowed in some case types See 12 CFR 263.73, citing to 263.53. In this case type, deposition procedures for formal hearings are applicable to informal hearings. In other case types (See 12 CFR 263.203 and 204), procedure for discovery is not specified. In 12 CFR 263.402, no discovery is permitted. | Not verified |
| 207 | Department of Agriculture | Office of the Chief Conservationist | USDANRCS0021 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | *Program Decisions: No discovery permitted. * NRCS Reconsideration of Preliminary Technical Determinations: As part of the reconsideration process for adverse preliminary technical determinations, a party, the designated conservationist who issued the preliminary determination, and a district representative (at the option of the conservation district), a district representative, conduct a field visit to the subject site "for the purpose of gathering additional information and discussing the [relevant] facts" to such determination. (7 CFR 614.7) * FSA County Committee Referral of Final Technical Determination Review to State Conservationist: If the FSA County Committee hearing the appeal of a technical determination under Title XII requests review of that determination by the State Conservationist, the State Conservationist designates "an appropriate NRCS official" to (a) any additional information needed for the review, and (b) obtain additional oral and documentary evidence from any party with personal knowledge; and (c) conduct a field visit. (7 CFR 614.10) | Not verified |
| 208 | Department of Energy | Office of the General Counsel | DOENCIVP0004 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | Each party must share with all other parties the names of both expert and lay witnesses along with a brief summary of their anticipated testimony, as well as copies and exhibits each party expects to introduce into evidence. See 10 CFR 820.28. In civil penalty cases under the Program Fraud Civil Penalties Act, the defendant may review any relevant and material documents, including those that either condemn or exculpate him or her, unless the documents are privileged. Documents should be made available for both inspection and copying. Depositions may also be required. See 10 CFR 1013.20, 1013.21, 1017.29(k)(6). | Not verified |
| 209 | Department of Housing and Urban Development | Departmental Enforcement Center | HUDODECO0009 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | No discovery takes places unless there is first a determination that fact-finding is required. Upon the debarring official's determination that fact-finding is necessary, the case will be referred to an administrative judge for fact-finding, and discovery will be available. Interrogatories, requests for production, and depositions are all permitted. | Verified |
| 210 | Department of Transportation | Office of the Assistant Secretary for Budget and Programs, or Office of the Assistant Secretary for Administration, or Head of the Operating Administration | DOTRDEBT0018 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | Various sections afford the debtor the right to inspect and copy the Department's records relating to the debt. See 49 CFR 92.11(b)(7) (administrative and salary offsets); see also 31 CFR 285.11(e)(2)(i) (wage garnishments). There is no similar provision in the regulations governing tax refund offsets, however. | Not verified |
| 211 | Department of Transportation | Office of the Secretary | DOTREMPL0019 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | -There is no express provision for discovery across all cases. Nevertheless, 49 CFR 98.7(c) states: "In a hearing under this part, the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and Evidence do not apply. However, the examiner may make such orders and determinations regarding discovery . . . and similar matters the examiner deems necessary or appropriate to ensure orderliness in the proceedings and fundamental fairness to the parties." | Not verified |
| 212 | Environmental Protection Agency | Office of Grants and Debarment | EPAOGRAN0005 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | EPA, in the Notice of Acknowledgment following a timely appeal, "may identify any additional information or documentation that is required for thorough consideration" of the challenged agency decision. (40 CFR 31.73(a)). The applicant/grantee challenging EPA's agency decision is not entitled to conduct discovery or request documents. | Not verified |
| 213 | Environmental Protection Agency | Office of Financial Management | EPAOOFFS0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | In salary offset cases, there is no "traditional" trial-type discovery. However, a debtor-employee may, upon request inspect and copy all EPA records relating to the debt. (30 CFR 13.22(c)(5)). No discovery or inspection is provided for in regulations covering administrative or tax refund offset cases. | Not verified |
| 214 | Equal Employment Opportunity Commission | Office of the Chief Human Capital Officer | EEOCDEBT0004 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | Employee-debtors are entitled to review and copy agency records related to the disputed debt. No other discovery permitted. | Verified |
| 215 | Farm Credit Administration | Unknown | FCAOSUSR0003 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | Formal rules of evidence apply as much as the Board says they apply in a particular proceeding. | Not verified |
| 216 | Federal Energy Regulatory Commission | Office of the Secretary | FERCCOMM0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | Proceedings Set for Hearing Under Subpart E: The Commission, as a hearing-level body, rarely conducts evidentiary hearings under Subpart E (18 CFR pt. 385, subpt. E). However, albeit rare, when the Commission does so, discovery available to parties is similar to federal district court. Discovery mechanisms include: depositions of parties, corporations/entities, non-parties, and experts; data requests; interrogatories;document requests; inspection requests; requests for admission. (18 CFR pt. 385, subpt. D). | Verified |
| 217 | Institute for Museum and Library Services | Office of General Counsel | IMLSNOND0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | As noted in 45 CFR 1110.9(d), the hearing, decision, and any administrative review is conducted in conformity with 5 U.S.C. 554-557. | Verified |
| 218 | National Science Foundation | Office of the General Counsel | NSFOFADJ0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | *Antarctic Conservation Act/PFCRA/Anti-Lobbying Cases: Parties are required at prehearing conference disclose names of their witnesses and experts, along with copies of documents they intend to introduce at the hearing. Other forms of discovery (e.g., depositions) permitted only at the hearing officer's discretion upon showing of necessity and unavailability of information through other means. (45 CFR 604.405 (lobbying restrictions), 672.12(e) (ACA), 45 CFR 681.18 (PFCRA)) *Civil Rights/De-funding Cases: None specified in NSF regulations. (See 45 CFR Parts 605, 611, 617, 618) | Not verified |
| 219 | Nuclear Regulatory Commission | Office of General Counsel | NRCOALJO0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | PFCRA : Full "traditional" discovery available (e.g., document requests, requests for admission, interrogatories, and depositions), though party seeking discovery must seek ALJ's approval to propound. (10 CFR 13.21) Debt Collection Cases: Formal discovery devices are not expressly provided for, but the governing regulations guarantee debtors the right to inspect and copy government records pertaining to the debt, or to request and receive a copy of these records if they cannot personally inspect them. (10 CFR 15.33(c)(1)(ii)(A), 16.7(b)(5)) Civil Rights Cases: No discovery permitted. | Not verified |
| 220 | Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission | Office of Administrative Law Judges | FMSHEAJA0004 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | 29 CFR 2704.306(b)-(c): On request of either the applicant or the Secretary, or on the ALJ's own initiative, the judge may order further proceedings, such as an informal conference, oral argument, additional written submissions or . . . pertinent discovery or an evidentiary hearing. If the proceeding was conceded by the Secretary on the merits, withdrawn by the Secretary, or otherwise settled before any of the merits were heard, the applicant and Secretary may supplement the record with affidavits and other documentary evidence | Not verified |
| 221 | Environmental Protection Agency | Regional Offices | EPAOCORR0003 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (Some Types of Cases) | For cases where corrective measures are necessary the respondent may file no more than 25 questions, including parts and subparts, to the EPA. See 40 CFR 24.14(d). The Hearing Officer can direct which questions the EPA has to answer at his discretion. He also may request the production of relevant papers, books, and documents. See 40 CFR 24.14(e). | Not verified |
| 222 | Federal Energy Regulatory Commission | Office of Administrative Law Judges and Dispute Resolution | FERCALJO0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Types and scope of discovery available for matters set for hearing under Subpart E is similar to federal district court. Discovery mechanisms include: depositions of parties, corporations/entities, non-parties, and experts; data requests; interrogatories;document requests; inspection requests; requests for admission. (18 CFR pt. 385, subpt. D). Discovery motions practice available, including: motions to compel, motions to quash subpoenas, or motions for order limiting discovery. ALJs also have the authority to sanction parties for discovery abuses or failure to comply with a discovery order. FERC rules expressly provide that parties have no continuing duty to supplement discovery responses. FERC has differentiated case management, which establishes default discovery time frames; ALJs have discretion to adjust as required to meet the needs of a case. | Verified |
| 223 | Federal Labor Relations Authority | Office of the Regional Director (7 Regional Offices) | FLRABREP0003 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | "Two (2) copies of documentary evidence shall be submitted and a copy furnished to each of the other parties." 22 CFR 1422.11(a) | Verified |
| 224 | Federal Labor Relations Authority | Office of Administrative Law Judges | FLRABULP0004 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Verified | |
| 225 | Federal Labor Relations Authority | Office of the Regional Director (7 Regional Offices) | FLRAREPE0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | "After a petition is filed, all parties must, upon request of the Regional Director, furnish the Regional Director and serve all parties affected by issues raised in the petition with information concerning parties, issues, and agreements raised in or affected by the petition." 5 CFR 2422.15(a) It is not true discovery in the civil litigation sense but information sharing. The process is not adversarial. | Verified |
| 226 | Federal Labor Relations Authority | Office of Administrative Law Judges | FLRAUNLP0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Parties must exchange "[p]roposed witness lists, including a brief synopsis of the expected testimony of each witness; [c]opies of documents, with an index, proposed to be offered into evidence; and [a] brief statement of the theory of the case, including relief sought, and any and all defenses to the allegations in the complaint." 5 CFR 2423.23 | Verified |
| 227 | Foreign Claims Settlement Commission | Commission | FCSCADJU0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Claimants may seek, upon Commission approval and issuance/order (as applicable), discovery through subpoenas duces tecum and depositions (oral or written). (45 CFR 501.2, 501.5) | Verified |
| 228 | Federal Maritime Commission | Office of Administrative Law Judges | FMCOSHIP0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Oral and written depositions, written interrogatories, production of documents, and requests for admission are all permitted under discovery. | Verified |
| 229 | Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission | Office of Administrative Law Judges | FMSHFADJ0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | *For All Matters Except Simplified Proceedings: Parties may obtain discovery of any relevant, non-privileged matter that is admissible evidence or appears to lead to discovery of admissible evidence (29 CFR 2700.56(b)).Methods of discovery include: depositions, interrogatories, requests for admissions, production of documents, and requests for permission to enter property for inspecting, copying, photographing, and gathering information. (29 CFR 2700.56(a)) * Simplified Proceedings (29 CFR 2700 Subpart J): Mandatory disclosure and exchange of information by parties within 45 days of designation of simplified proceeding. Disclosures cover any information in parties' possession, custody or control that may be used to support claim or defense. Disclosing party must provide privilege log for non-disclosed documents withheld on basis of privilege. Aside from mandatory disclosures, no additional discovery permitted in simplified proceedings except as ordered by presiding ALJ. | Verified |
| 230 | National Transportation Safety Board | Office of Administrative Law Judges | NTSBAPPE0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions, interrogatories, and other forms of discovery are allowed. Per 49 CFR 821.5 Procedural Rules, for situations not covered by the Boards Rules of Practice the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure are applicable to the extent practicable. | Verified |
| 231 | Occupational Safety & Health Review Commission | Office of the Chief Administrative Law Judge | OSHRADJU0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Discovery is conducted in conventional proceedings, but discouraged (though permitted) in simplified proceedings. The information sought through discovery may include any matter that is relevant and not privileged, regardless of whether it is ultimately admissible at the hearing. The judge may limit discovery that is unreasonably cumulative or duplicative or unduly burdensome or expensive. The types of discovery available include: production of documents or things or permission to enter land or property; requests for admission; interrogatories; and depositions. See 29 CFR 2200.52 through 2200.56. | Verified |
| 232 | Federal Trade Commission | Office of Administrative Law Judges | FTCAADJU0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Discovery process and types similar to federal district court actions: mandatory initial disclosures; depositions (oral or written); interrogatories; requests for admission; document requests; expert disclosures and discovery; subpoenas duces tecum, ad testificandum, and for inspection. Motion practice (e.g., motions to compel, motions for protective order) permitted by parties and heard by ALJ. (16 CFR 3.31 - 3.40). | Verified |
| 233 | Merit Systems Protection Board | Office of Regional Operations | MSPBAPPJ0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | "Full" federal-court type discovery available to parties based on methods available in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (e.g., interrogatories, requests for documents or inspection, depositions, requests for admission). Absent prior approval, however, interrogatories limited to 25, and depositions to not more than 10. (5 CFR 1201.71 - 1201.83) | Not verified |
| 234 | Merit Systems Protection Board | Office of the Administrative Law Judge | MSPBORIG0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | "Full" federal-court type discovery available to parties based on methods available in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (e.g., interrogatories, requests for documents or inspection, depositions, requests for admission). Absent prior approval, however, interrogatories limited to 25, and depositions to not more than 10. (5 CFR 1201.71 - 1201.83) | Not verified |
| 235 | National Credit Union Administration | Board | NCUABDAP0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Discovery is permitted only through the production of documents, or the deposition of a person producing documents pursuant to a document subpoena (questions limited to identification of documents produced and whether the search for the documents was adequate). A party may obtain document discovery regarding any matter, not privileged, that has material relevance to the merits of the pending action. | Not verified |
| 236 | Nuclear Regulatory Commission | Office of the Secretary | NRCOSUBJ0010 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Discovery by parties, potential parties, and interested governmental participants during pre-license HLW application proceedings comes in several forms. First, each party/participant must make electronically available (subject to privilege or other applicable legal protections) all documentary materials on which it intends to rely/cite in the proceedings. Each party/participant must designate an official responsible for ensuring compliance with rules concerning electronic documents. Second, parties/participants may -- as of right -- conduct additional discovery using requests for inspection (land or raw data), and oral depositions; and requests for admission. Third, parties/participants may seek permission from the discovery master to propound interrogatories or depositions upon written questions. (10 CFR 2.1018) (Note: For proceedings in which NRC Staff is a party, there a special provisions relating to form and scope of discovery available from NRC employees. (See 10 CFR 2.709)) | Not verified |
| 237 | Nuclear Regulatory Commission | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board | NRCOSUBL0005 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | In Subpart L proceedings, NRC staff are obligated to make the "hearing file" publicly available on the NRC web site and/or NRC Public Document Room. The hearing file is required to contain, among other things, the license application, any amendments, NRC staff technical/safety reports and/or environmental reports on the application; and any correspondence between the applicant/licensee and NRC related to the application. NRC staff have the ongoing obligation of keeping the hearing file up to date. In all other respects, discovery is prohibited. (10 CFR 2.1203) (Note: In expedited proceedings under Subpart N, discovery is prohibited, and NRC staff does not post a hearing file. See 10 CFR pt. 2, subpt. N.) | Not verified |
| 238 | Nuclear Regulatory Commission | Office of the Secretary | NRCOSUBM0006 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | In all Subpart M proceedings, NRC is required to post on the agency's web site specified documents relating to the transfer application, including: the application and related requests, NRC correspondence with the applicant/licensee related to the application, NRC Staff Evaluation Reports (SER), and any NRC staff orders acting on the application (i.e., granting or denying the license transfer application). No other discovery -- including party-conducted discovery -- is otherwise permitted. | Not verified |
| 239 | United States Postal Service | Office of the Administrative Law Judge | USPSJOAJ0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | ALJ determines based on requests of the parties. | Verified |
| 240 | United States Postal Service | United States Postal Service Board of Contract Appeals | USPSPBCA0003 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Discovery is general broad, and can include depositions, interrogatories, admission of facts, and production of documents (See 39 CFR 955.15-16). | Verified |
| 241 | United States Parole Commission | Commission | USPCLABR0005 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | The applicant must attach an affidavit setting forth several items concerning the applicant's personal history which are relevant to the case, such as any present employment or past association with labor organizations or employee benefit plans. 28 CFR 4.4. Additionally, each application must be accompanied by 6 letters or forms of statement attesting to the character and reputation of the applicant. 28 CFR 4.5. Pursuant to section 556 of the APA, the hearing officer may take depositions or have depositions taken as necessary. | Not verified |
| 242 | United States Parole Commission | Commission | USPCMAIN0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | The prisoner/parolee is permitted to view his/her institutional file before the hearing and may inspect any parts that the Commission will use as a basis for its decision. If any portions of the file are exempted, by law, from being shown, those portions will be summarized and the summaries will be provided to the offender, if requested. 28 CFR 2.55 | Not verified |
| 243 | United States Parole Commission | Commission | USPCREVC0004 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | All evidence upon which the finding of violation may be based shall be disclosed to the parolee at or before the revocation hearing. The hearing officer or examiner panel may disclose documentary evidence by permitting the parolee to examine the document during the hearing, or where appropriate, by reading or summarizing the document in the presence of the parolee. 28 CFR 2.50(d) | Not verified |
| 244 | United States Postal Service | Office of the Judicial Officer | USPSJOJO0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Broad discovery; most case types allow for depositions and interrogatories, some case types also allow for requests for admission and requests for production of documents. Hearing officer can limit discovery to avoid inefficiency or harassment, and issue sanctions for failure to appear or produce information. See 39 CFR 952.21, 954.16(d), 957.18, 959.20, 962.12, 963.14 and 964.9 | Not verified |
| 245 | United States Parole Commission | Commission | USPCTRNF0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Transferee and his/her counsel have an opportunity to read and discuss the postsentence investigation report. | Not verified |
| 246 | Department of Health and Human Services | Office of Administrative Law Judges | HHSOCRDB0009 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions, interrogatories and document requests are allowed. | Not verified |
| 247 | Copyright Royalty Tribunal | Copyright Royalty Board | CRTRADJU0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Discovery varies depending on case type. For distribution proceedings, the Copyright Royalty Judge designates a 45 day period in which parties may request non-privileged documents related to written exhibits and testimony. See 37 CFR 351.6. In royalty rate proceedings, discovery includes requests for document production, depositions, and interrogatories. See 37 CFR 351.5. | Not verified |
| 248 | Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System | Office of Financial Institution Adjudication | FRSXOFIA0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Parties may request document production and conduct depositions (12 CFR 263.24, 263.53), but interrogatories are not permitted. Parties may discover documents regarding "any matter, not privileged, that has material relevance to the merits of the pending action" (12 CFR 263.24(b)). | Not verified |
| 249 | Department of Commerce | United States Coast Guard Office of Administrative Law Judges | USDCBISF0003 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Discovery may include: interrogatories, requests for admissions, and requests for production of documents in accordance with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Additionally, upon a showing of good cause the ALJ will allow depositions. 15 CFR 766.9(c) | Verified |
| 250 | Department of Commerce | Office of the Under Secretary | USDCDUMP0006 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Parties are encouraged to engage in voluntary discovery procedures regarding any non-privileged matter relevant to the proceeding. See 19 CFR 354.10. "A party may serve on any other party interrogatories, requests for admissions, or requests for production of documents for inspection and copying." 19 CFR 354.10(b). Additionally, a party may apply for depositions, and upon a showing of good cause the presiding official can order the deposition of any party or under the control or authority of the party. See 19 CFR 354.10(c). | Verified |
| 251 | Department of Commerce | National Appeals Office | USDCNNAO0013 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | "Parties shall exchange all exhibits that will be offered at the hearing at least 10 days before the hearing." 15 CFR 906.9(b) However, "[p]arties may not compel discovery or the testimony of any witness." 15 CFR 906.11(a)(7) | Not verified |
| 252 | Department of Commerce | Office of Administrative Law Judges | USDCNOAA0009 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Required discovery includes: "[a] factual summary of the case; a summary of all factual and legal issues in dispute; a list of all defenses that will be asserted, together with a summary of all factual and legal bases supporting each defense; a list of all potential witnesses, together with a summary of their anticipated testimony; and a list of all potential exhibits." 15 CFR 904.240(a)(1). Upon written motion, the following forms of discovery may also be permitted: depositions, interrogatories, admissions, and production of documents and the opportunity to inspect them. See 15 CFR 904.240(a)(b). | Not verified |
| 253 | Department of Justice | Office of the Chief Immigration Judge | DOJXEOIR0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | If an Immigration Judge is satisfied that a witness is not reasonably available at the place of hearing and that said witness' testimony or other evidence is essential, the Immigration Judge may order the taking of deposition either at his or her own instance or upon application of a party. Such order shall designate the official by whom the deposition shall be taken, may prescribe and limit the content, scope, or manner of taking the deposition, and may direct the production of documentary evidence. 8 CFR 1003.35(a) If the witness is at a distance of more than 100 miles from the place of the proceeding, the subpoena shall provide for the witness' appearance at the Immigration Court nearest to the witness to respond to oral or written interrogatories, unless there is no objection by any party to the witness' appearance at the proceeding. 8 CFR 1003.35(b)(4) | Verified |
| 254 | Department of Justice | Office of the Chief Administrative Hearing Officer | DOJXEOIR0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Parties may obtain discovery by one or more of the following methods: depositions upon oral examination or written questions; written interrogatories; production of documents or things, or permission to enter upon land or other property, for inspection and other purposes; physical and mental examinations; and requests for admissions. The frequency or extent of these methods may be limited by the Administrative Law Judge upon his or her own initiative or pursuant to a motion for a protective order. 28 CFR 68.18. | Verified |
| 255 | Government Accountability Office | Contract Appeals Board | GAOOCONT0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions, interrogatories, requests for admission, production of documents. | Not verified |
| 256 | Nuclear Regulatory Commission | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board | NRCOSUBG0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Full "traditional" discovery -- patterned after FRCP 26 -- available. Parties (other than NRC staff) have mandatory disclosure obligations, which may be supplemented by document requests, written interrogatories, requests for inspection, depositions, and requests for admission. Motions for protective orders permitted. Seasonable supplementation of discovery responses required. (10 CFR 2.705 - 2.708) Note: For proceedings in which NRC Staff is a party, there a special provisions relating to form and scope of discovery available from NRC employees. (See 10 CFR 2.709) | Not verified |
| 257 | Department of State | Foreign Service Grievance Board | DOSFSGBA0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | While traditional court-type discovery is unavailable, and grievant may request copies of agency documents or records related to the grievance, subject to privilege or national security considerations. The documents normally shall be provided within 15 days of a request. (22 CFR 16.3(b)(2); 3 FAM 4426.1) | Not verified |
| 258 | Department of Transportation | Office of Hearings | DOTRFAAD0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions in accordance with section 1004 of the Federal Aviation Act of 1958 or Rule 26 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Interrogatories and requests for the production of documents are also permissible means of discovery. | Not verified |
| 259 | Department of Transportation | Office of Airport Compliance and Management Analysis | DOTRFAAD0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Discovery is limited to requests for admissions, requests for production of documents, interrogatories, and depositions. | Not verified |
| 260 | Department of Transportation | Office of Hearings | DOTRFRRA0005 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Not verified | |
| 261 | Department of Transportation | Office of Hearings | DOTRMERC0006 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | 46 CFR 201.109 - request for production of documents; 46 CFR 201.110 - depositions and written interrogatories; 46 CFR 201.122 - subpoenas duces tecum. Though available across all case types, these discovery methods are only permitted upon motion to the presiding officer. See id. | Not verified |
| 262 | Department of Transportation | Office of Hearings | DOTRNHTS0007 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Parties may obtain discovery by one or more of the following methods: (1) Written interrogatories; (2) requests for production of documents or things; (3) requests for admissions; or (4) testimony upon oral examination. Unless the Presiding Officer otherwise orders under paragraph (d) of this section, the frequency of use of these methods is not limited. | Not verified |
| 263 | Department of Transportation | Office of Hearings | DOTROOSE0009 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions | Not verified |
| 264 | Department of Transportation | Office of Hearings | DOTRPRFR0011 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Interrogatories, requests for production, requests for admissions and depositions. Unless the parties agree, discovery is available only as ordered by the ALJ upon motion. See 49 CFR 31.21(c). The ALJ authorizes discovery only when it satisfies/does not offend the conditions in 49 CFR 31.21(d)(3). | Not verified |
| 265 | Department of Veterans Affairs | Office of Administrative Law Judges | DOVAPFCR0007 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Discovery is only available as ordered by the ALJ. The types of discovery include: (1) requests for production of documents for inspection and copying; (2) requests for admissions of the authenticity of any relevant document or the truth of any relevant fact; (3) written interrogatories; and (4) depositions. See 38 CFR 42.21 | Not verified |
| 266 | Equal Employment Opportunity Commission | Office of Field Programs | EEOCFEDS0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Parties have a right to conduct discovery as needed for "reasonable development of evidence." If the parties cannot agree in writing to the methods and scope of discovery, the propounding party may seek authorization from the AJ. Potential discovery methods include: interrogatories, depositions, document requests, and requests for admission. (29 CFR 1614.109(d)) | Verified |
| 267 | Equal Employment Opportunity Commission | Office of Federal Operations | EEOCGOVT0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | "Full" federal court-type discovery available as of right to parties. Discovery may include: interrogatories (up to 20); depositions; document requests; and requests for admission. Discovery proceedings are governed by the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. (29 CFR 1603.210) | Verified |
| 268 | Federal Communications Commission | Investigations and Hearings Division | FCCOINHD0004 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Parties may take depositions, send interrogatories, or make requests for production of documents. | Not verified |
| 269 | Federal Communications Commission | Enforcement Bureau | FCCOMDRD0008 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Each party, with its initial pleading, shall serve copies of all documents in the possession, custody or control of the party that are likely to bear significantly on any claim or defense. In pre-status conference, parties may request the production of additional document, seek leave to conduct a reasonable number of depositions. However, interrogatories should not be routinely granted. Parties may also obtain expert witnesses, but they are also subject to depositions. | Not verified |
| 270 | Federal Communications Commission | Enforcement Bureau | FCCOMDRD0010 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Scope of discovery is determined on a case-by-case basis. The Commission (or its delegated authority) may in its discretion order discovery limited to the issues specified by the Commission. Such discovery may include answers to written interrogatories, depositions, document production, or requests for admissions. | Not verified |
| 271 | Federal Communications Commission | Enforcement Bureau | FCCOTCCD0011 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Complainant may file up to 10 written interrogatories. Additional discovery is at the discretion of the hearing officer, but may include document production, depositions, or additional interrogatories. See 47 C.F.R. § 14.47. | Not verified |
| 272 | Department of the Interior | Office of the OHA Director | DINTAHOC0005 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Not verified | |
| 273 | Department of the Interior | Departmental Cases Hearings Division | DINTDEPT0004 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Witnesses, application for subpoena | Not verified |
| 274 | Department of the Interior | Endangered Species Committee | DINTESAC0008 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Not verified | |
| 275 | Department of the Treasury | Office of Administrative Law Judges | TRSYALJS0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Oral and written depositions allowed for all cases (31 C.F.R. 501.730 - 501.731, 10.71), and requests for admission are also allowed for IRS disciplinary cases (31 C.F.R. 10.71). TTB: Depositions generally allowed for all cases. 27 C.F.R. 71.125. Production of documents can be required by subpoena. 27 C.F.R. 71.125 - 71.126. The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure are deemed a guide for any other manner of discovery not specifically provided for by TTB's regulations. 27 C.F.R. 71.2. | Verified |
| 276 | Department of the Interior | Interior Board of Land Appeals | DINTIBLA0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | ALJ may subpoena witnesses, depositions 43 CFR 4.423; governed by the Act of January 31, 1903 (43 U.S.C. 102-106), and 28 U.S.C. 1821. | Not verified |
| 277 | Department of the Interior | Indian Probate Hearings Division | DINTPROB0003 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | May request documents, depositions, interrogatories, admission of facts. The judge may limit the time, place and scope of discovery. | Not verified |
| 278 | Department of Justice | Access Review Committee | DOJXCLAS0014 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | The applicant may request documents, records or reports, including the entire investigative file upon which a denial or revocation is based. 28 CFR 17.47(a)(2). | Not verified |
| 279 | Department of Justice | Office of the Administrative Law Judges | DOJXDRUG0008 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Discovery may be obtained by one or more of the methods provided under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, including: written interrogatories, depositions, requests for production of documents or things for inspection or copying, and requests for admission addressed to parties. 28 CFR 76.21. | Not verified |
| 280 | Department of Energy | Office of Hearings and Appeals | DOENOOHA0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Discovery includes depositions and documents produced in response to a subpoena. See 10 CFR 1003.8; 10 CFR 708.28. | Verified |
| 281 | Department of Housing and Urban Development | Office of Hearings and Appeals | HUDOHALJ0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | All Pt. 26 Cases: discovery is available upon agreement of parties or as ordered by the ALJ. Forms of discovery available: requests for productions of documents, written interrogatories, and oral depositions, and requests for admission. Discovery-related motions practice (e.g., motions to compel and for protective order) are also permitted. See 24 CFR 26.42 - 26.44; 26.18; 24 CFR pt. 180, subpt. E. Rules governing civil rights matters also impose a supplementation duty on parties. 24 CFR 180.505. ALJ may order discovery necessary for expeditious, fair and reasonable consideration of issues. // PFCRA cases: The defendant has right to review, upon request to General Counsel, any exculpatory or nonprivileged documents related to the complaint. Apart from that only limited discovery is permitted at the discretion of the ALJ who determines it necessary for the fair consideration of the issues without being unduly costly or unreasonably delaying the proceedings. See 24 CFR 26.42(b). | Verified |
| 282 | Department of Commerce | HUD Office of Administrative Law Judges | USDCPDIS0023 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Apart from a pre-hearing statement to be issued prior to the hearing at the request of the hearing officer, a party may be entitled to reasonable and relevant discovery at the discretion of the hearing officer including: "[1] a reasonable number of written requests for admission or interrogatories; (2) Produce for inspection and copying a reasonable number of documents; and (3) Produce for inspection a reasonable number of things other than documents." See 37 CFR 11.52(a). Depositions may be taken for use at the hearing in lieu of the personal appearance of a witness upon a showing of good cause and approval of the hearing officer. See 37 CFR 11.51(a). | Verified |
| 283 | Consumer Financial Protection Bureau | Office of Administrative Adjudication | CFPBADJU0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | The Office of Enforcement, according to an order by the hearing officer, must make documents obtained by the office prior to the beginning of the administrative proceeding available to the respondent for inspection and copying. As well, each party must provide the other with a report prepared by each of its expert witnesses. See 12 CFR 1081.206, 1081.210. In addition, parties are able to request the issuance of document subpoenas. | Verified |
| 284 | Commodity Futures Trading Commission | Office of Proceedings | CFTCREPA0005 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Written discovery available in all proceedings: document production requests; depositions on written interrogatories; and requests for admission. See 17 CFR 12.30 - 12.34. | Verified |
| 285 | Department of Agriculture | Office of the Administrative Law Judges | USDAOALJ0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions and subpoenas only. For depositions, parties must file motions with the ALJ naming potential deponent and basis for request which, by rule, "shall solely be for the purpose of eliciting testimony which might not otherwise be available at the time of the hearing." (See 7 CFR § 1.148(b)(4)) | Not verified |
| 286 | Commodity Futures Trading Commission | Office of Proceedings | CFTCFORM0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | The scope of discovery is broad and involves all non-confidential documentation relevant to the case. Parties are required to make prehearing disclosures, including: case outline; legal theories; identity and location of lay and expert witnesses, and summaries of expected testimony; investigatory materials (from Division of Enforcement); list of documents to be introduced at hearing; and index of withheld documents. Parties may also seek permission to take depositions (oral or through written interrogatories) under certain circumstances. (See 17 CFR 10.41 - .44). | Verified |
| 287 | Consumer Product Safety Commission | United States Coast Guard Administrative Law Judges | CPSCPENA0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | 16 CFR 1025.31 (b) Discovery methods. Parties may obtain discovery by one or more of the following methods: (1) Written interrogatories; (2) Requests for production of documents or things; (3) Requests for admission; or (4) Depositions upon oral examination. | Not verified |
| 288 | Department of Health and Human Services | Office of Administrative Law Judges | HHSOADGA0008 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions, interrogatories and document requests are allowed. | Verified |
| 289 | Department of Education | Office of Administrative Law Judges | DOEDCRRA0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions, interrogatories, and document requests are allowed. | Verified |
| 290 | Department of Education | Office of Administrative Law Judges | DOEDOGBR0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions, interrogatories, and document requests are allowed. | Verified |
| 291 | Department of Education | Office of Higher Education Appeals | DOEDOHEA0003 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions, interrogatories, and document requests are allowed. | Verified |
| 292 | Department of Health and Human Services | Office of Hearings and Inquiries | HHSOFDVA0007 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Part 12 does not directly address discovery; however, 12.92(b)(2) indicates that, in developing evidence on issues in controversy, the presiding officer may consider the exchange of written interrogatories directed to particular witnesses. 21 CFR 16.24(g) provides that FDA and the party requesting the hearing will, if feasible, at least 1 day before the hearing provide to each other written notice of any published articles or written information to be presented at or relied on at the hearing. A copy will also be provided in advance if the other participant could not reasonably be expected to have or be able to obtain a copy. If written notice or a copy is not provided, the presiding officer may, if time permits, allow the party who did not receive the notice or copy additional time after the close of the hearing to make a submission concerning the article or information. 21 CFR 17.23 provides that no later than 60 days prior to the hearing, unless otherwise ordered by the presiding officer, a party may make a request to another party for production, inspection, and copying of documents that are relevant to the issues before the presiding officer. Documents must be provided no later than 30 days after the request has been made. The term "documents" is defined to include information, reports, answers, records, accounts, papers and other data and documentary evidence. The regulation also provides a party the opportunity to file a motion for a protective order. The presiding officer may order depositions only when the showings in 21 CFR 17.23(e) are met. | Verified |
| 293 | Department of Homeland Security | Office of the Chief Administrative Law Judge | DHSCCGFM0005 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Witness lists with expected testimony, exhibits. Further forms of discovery are available only by ALJ's order, including interrogatories, depositions, and document production. 33 CFR 20 Subpart F. | Verified |
| 294 | Department of Homeland Security | Coast Guard Hearing Office | DHSCCGHP0004 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | "The alleged violator may, upon request, receive a free copy of all the written evidence in the case file, except material that would disclose or lead to the disclosure of the identity of a confidential informant. Other evidence or material, such as blueprints, sound or video tapes, oil samples, and photographs may be examined in the Hearing Officer's offices. The Hearing Officer may provide for examination or testing of evidence at other locations if there are adequate safeguards to prevent loss or tampering." 33 CFR 1.07-30 | Verified |
| 295 | Department of Homeland Security | Coast Guard Retiring Review Board | DHSCCGRR0006 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Evidence may be submitted to the Board by oral testimony under oath, or in the form of depositions or affidavits. 33 CFR 50.4(g). | Verified |
| 296 | Department of Labor | Office of Administrative Law Judges (OALJ) | LABROALJ0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions upon oral examination or written questions; written interrogatories; production of documents or other evidence for inspection and other purposes; and requests for admission. (29 CFR § 18.13) | Verified |
| 297 | Environmental Protection Agency | Office of Administrative Law Judges | EPAOOALJ0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | The Rules of Procedure generally provide for parties to engage in a "prehearing information exchange," which includes, but is not limited to, providing the opposing party or parties (and the Tribunal) with a list of anticipated lay and expert witnesses to be called at hearing along with summaries of their expected testimony; copies of all documents and exhibits expected to be introduced at the hearing; and the agency's calculations for proposed penalties (in cases seeking civil penalties) or Respondent's bases for challenging the penalty, including an inability to pay. Parties have an affirmative obligation to supplement their exchanges if it is discovered that the information is incomplete, inaccurate, or out of date. Additional discovery is permitted only upon motion and leave from the presiding ALJ. Such additional discovery generally involves depositions and requests for admission, but can also involve interrogatories, document production, site visits, sample testing, etc. (See 40 C.F.R. § 22.19). In addition, parties are strongly encouraged to stipulate to uncontested facts and witness testimony prior to hearing so that the limited time allocated to hearing can efficiently focus on factual matters actually in dispute. Parties are also permitted to file pre-hearing motions to narrow the issues for hearing and pre-hearing briefs to set forth their positions regarding factual and legal matters in dispute. | Verified |
| 298 | United States International Trade Commission | Office of the Administrative Law Judges | ITCXALJS0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Depositions, interrogatories, Requests for Production, ESI, Requests for Admissions, etc. | Verified |
| 299 | National Labor Relations Board | Regional Offices | NLRBREPR0002 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Parties may request and obtain subpoeanas for production of documents and witnesses at hearing. | Verified |
| 300 | Government Accountability Office | Personnel Appeals Board | GAOOPERS0001 - Hearing Level - Procedures | Yes (All Types of Cases) | Federal Rules of Civil Procedure provide guidance, but they are not mandatory. Deposition, subpoena, interrogatories, and admissions are permitted. | Verified |
Pages
